“Are you better off this year than last?” This is a question that many in our country consider to be one of the most meaningful questions of this season.
The question is asked polemically or triumphantly, out of real concern or out of anger and disgust. It is asked in multi-million dollar attack ads and in intimate dialogues around the kitchen table. Everyone feels obliged to respond to that question. Everyone seems to feel moved to deal with this central question on a personal basis and on behalf of the entire country.
But it is the wrong question.
The central question of this season is not whether we are better off, but whether we are better. Are we better than we were last year? Have we grown at all in our dealings with our loved ones? With our co- workers? Our community and society? Are we better this year than last year in dealing with our own limitations and failings and demons? Are we better at fulfilling our commitments and dreams? Are we better human beings? Are we better Jews?